I don't know whether or not this is true, and the truth of the ClimateGate theory isn't critical to my blog today.All this talk of wealth distribution got me thinking about the idea of socialism. I am not a philosophy major. I never was big on discussing the finer points of distinction between fascism, socialism, communism or Marxism.... that's a lot of isms.... My general understanding is that they all basically advocate taking from those who have and giving to those who don't because it isn't fair that someone has more than another. So, what's wrong with that? What's wrong with sharing?

Nothing is wrong with sharing, as any pre-schooler learns. Pre-schoolers also know that taking isn't sharing. Taking hurts the person you take from. Imagine the scene: A two year old walks up and takes the fire truck her brother is playing with. "I'll give it back in just a minute. I want to play with it." The brother's face falls, his eyes getting big, lower lip quivering with shock. The big sister walks away smugly and, having gotten something for nothing, plays with the firetruck for 30 seconds, tosses it aside (literally) and walks away. What has anyone learned? The brother learned not to trust his sister 'cause she takes his stuff and the sister learns she can have whatever she wants. And she doesn't even appreciate it.

On a more macro scale, a person who takes learns they can take. They don't appreciate it, nor do they treat what is given to them with respect. This applies whether what's being taken is a toy firetruck or money. It's could be called tax or carbon credit or welfare. Most importantly, the taker doesn't learn how to work hard. And let's face it, life is hard work, whether you have to study spelling words, take care of kids, jockey a desk or run a business. Without a basic ability to work hard, a person will never succeed at life, regardless of their job.
Taking also deprives an individual of the lesson that life isn't fair. It's not fair that one child grows up in poverty and another with extreme wealth. It's not fair that one family struggles to pay the medical bills for a sick child, while another family barely suffers from the common cold. The fact is, life is not fair. Through this understanding that life isn't fair, we can learn to be happy, despite what we don't have.
This is why we will not practice socialism in our family, however, we do occasionally practice dictatorship, capitalism and anarchy.
The second part of this little blog on family government will discuss what the "giver" and "taker" miss out on when things are given instead of taken.
Lysa
PS-- No children were ignored in the writing of this blog, which is why it took 2+ hours to write, and still sucks.



















